Get started with your PeaceJam education through our programs, curriculum, and presentations
Connect with PeaceJammers and learn about the people who inspire us
Get involved with the Global Call to Action and PeaceJam's Service Learning programs
Husbands, Wives in France can be jailed for insulting eachother
Posted 7/2/2010 at 11:09 AM by Bradlee A in Community Blog
Affiliate: PeaceJam HQ
Under a new French law, couples who insult each other can now be fined or jailed. The law is intended to protect citizens from the effects of "psychological violence."

Henry Samuel, The Telegraph wrote:
The law – the first of its kind – means that partners who make such insults or threats of physical violence faces up to three years in prison and a €75,000 (£60,000) fine.

...

The bill, which has been unanimously approved by French MPs, defines mental violence as "repeated acts that could be constituted by words," including insults or repeated text messages that "degrade one's quality of life and cause a change to one's mental or physical state."

Opponents of the law claim an insult is too vague and verbal abuse is too hard to prove. However, proponents of the law say

Henry Samuel, The Telegraph wrote:
Nadine Morano, the junior family minister, told the National Assembly that "we have introduced an important measure here, which recognises psychological violence, because it isn't just blows (that hurt), but also words."

Miss Morano said the primary abuse help line for French women got 90,000 calls a year, with 84 per cent concerning psychological violence.

To read the article in full click here.

PeaceJam wants to know what you think about this new law. Will it help to protect those in abusive relationships or does it go too far? Is this an important step for the rights of women and children or is it too drastic?


For more information on PeaceJam's Global Call to Action issue Rights For Women and Children and Their Role As Leaders, click here.
Share |
12
Dawn E wrote:
It will be very interesting to see the effects of this new law -- this is something that I would like to follow and find out more about... I wonder if it will work?
posted 7/2/2010 at 5:05 PM
Joshua H wrote:
I like this law. To often these verbal threats go unpunished. Although verbal abuse may be hard to prove, I think this law could go a long way to deter people from committing this form of violence on one another.
posted 7/2/2010 at 9:31 PM
Steve S wrote:
I'm curious how the term 'repeated' is defined here. No one is immune to isolated cases of verbal irresponsibility. Plus, anyone who has been in a serious relationship knows that petty arguments can take on a life of their own where things get said that are about 300 degrees of separation away from how a person actually feels.

It's cool to protect people from real physical, or emotional harm. But it's lame if it also lumps in petty and personal events and makes them a matter for the courts.
posted 7/4/2010 at 3:42 PM
Brett E wrote:
I think there is merit in the idea but I'd need more details to know whether it goes too far or not. I do worry about a law like this being abused but I also think verbal violence can definitely mess someone's life up. Tough too choose a side here.
posted 7/4/2010 at 8:45 PM
Bradlee A wrote:
It's great that they are recognizing psychological violence as a crime, because I completely agree that it is. I fear that it may go too far like Steve said:

Steve S wrote:
It's cool to protect people from real physical, or emotional harm. But it's lame if it also lumps in petty and personal events and makes them a matter for the courts.
posted 7/14/2010 at 2:03 PM
Kayla P wrote:
I like this, but I agree with what most of you guys are saying--it is kind of vague and may go too far. One of the complications is intention. Sometimes words come out differently than intended. How can the true intention/whether the insult was psychologically harmful be judged? I also agree that it is hard to prove. Besides longterm behavioral and mental changes, what kind of evidence could be used to prove/disprove a claim against a spouse?
posted 7/14/2010 at 3:46 PM
© 2008 - 2012 The PeaceJam Foundation